When CBS announced the brand-new reboot of The Twilight Zone quite some time ago, the network had already attached Jordan Peele as an executive producer. But thanks to the new ad that dropped during the Super Bowl, we’ve been able to catch a glimpse of the horror auteur in his other role for the series: as the even-keeled host of the show itself, just like the original’s Rod Serling. The new teaser is appropriately creepy, setting up the strange multiverse we’ve come to expect from the mysterious show. Did the Super Bowl really happen, or was it just a figment of our imaginations?! We’ll find out when the reboot drops on April 1. In the meantime, you can check out the star-packed cast and scour the teaser for Easter eggs.